Is Your Agency Future-Proof? Why 2026 Demands a New Standard of Capability
How does a CMO know that the agency partnership forged five years ago possesses the technical and strategic muscle required for the next five years?
In 2026, the stakes for Agency selection have never been higher. Evaluating and appointing a partner remains one of the most significant capital outlays an advertiser will make. Yet, as the media landscape shifts from "complex" to "hyper-fragmented," traditional chemistry-based assessments are no longer enough.
To ensure an agency selection is robust today and resilient tomorrow, marketers must move toward sophisticated, data-driven evaluations.
Evidence-Based Decisions: The Bedrock of Sustainability
Having designed and managed some of the most high-stakes media pitches for brands like LVMH, T-Mobile, and Uber, we’ve identified three non-negotiable pillars for a successful appointment:
-
Organizational Alignment: Stakeholders across procurement, marketing, and data science must have an objective voice in the process to ensure long-term buy-in.
-
Evidence-Based Scrutiny: Decisions must be defended by rigorous assessment, ensuring the appointment isn't dismissed as a 'subjective whim' when quarterly performance is reviewed.
-
Built-in Sustainability: A high-value agency contract should outlast the average CMO’s tenure. You shouldn't be forced into a redo because the original scope was too narrow.
Chasing a Moving Target
The challenge for most marketers isn't a lack of ambition; it’s that the target won't stop moving. The underlying media market (and the agencies within it) are in a state of constant evolution.
Our audits frequently show that agency contracts become obsolete within 18 months. Why? Because they fail to account for innovations in AI-driven planning and the maturation of programmatic processes.
In 2026, viewing programmatic as a kind of media channel is a mistake. Contracts that still rely on antiquated commission structures for programmatic spend fail to recognize the complexity of the modern supply chain and the need for Media Transparency.
Testing Capabilities for the Real World
Assessment shouldn't happen in a vacuum. To find a partner that fits your brand’s needs for the next decade, you have to test their capabilities using real data and live workstreams.
In the meantime, you can access our proprietary templates and toolkits for running a high-standard process at our dedicated resource hub: Running An Agency Pitch.
Brands deserve more from their media investments. By making qualified decisions based on evidence, we reduce risk and recoup the hidden waste in the supply chain. When brands get the media they deserve, they flourish.
When brands grow, we all win.
COMMENTS