Media Consolidation, AI Ads & the Trade Desk | #MediaSnack
If you are a CMO, Procurement Director or Global Head of Media, you are being asked to make confident choices in a market that no longer stands still. Media owners keep getting bigger, new AI answer engines keep appearing and the open internet is starting to look fragile.
In this #MediaSnack Live episode, we unpack three signals you cannot ignore.
First, a fresh wave of mega mergers between media owners, from Fox and Roku to Skydance and Warner to DoorDash and Instacart.
Second, AI search and answer engines opening their doors to advertisers.
Third, some uncomfortable Q3 numbers out of The Trade Desk.
This recap turns that conversation into a short executive playbook. You will see what is really going on, why it matters commercially, and how to reset your gameplan so you protect pricing power, data access and your competitive advantage in media.
The ID Comms Breakdown
In this episode we explain how media consolidation and AI answer engines are shifting power toward platforms, why The Trade Desk's flat Q3 matters for the open web, and what CMOs and procurement must do now to protect pricing power, data access and governance.
What's going on?
We start with a tour of the latest mega mergers. Fox has, in the episode scenario, completed a 22 billion dollar acquisition of Roku. That gives Fox control of Roku's inventory across multiple platforms and, more importantly, access to the streaming behavior of around 100 million households.
We then highlight Skydance's acquisition of Warner Brothers and its planned 6 billion dollar cost reduction program sitting on top of roughly 80 billion dollars of debt. Buried in that synergy target is about 1 billion dollars in reduced marketing investment. That is a direct cut in demand for media inventory.
Finally, we discuss DoorDash's 17 billion dollar acquisition of Instacart as a way to capture retail media data and shopper budgets. All of this plays out in a market where, as we remind viewers, around 60 percent of a roughly one trillion dollar global media market already flows through just three platforms.
What are the implications?
The commercial logic behind each deal is the same. Whoever controls the data and the technology can place better bets, defend margins and dictate terms. For Fox plus Roku, that means vertical integration in CTV across content, operating system, ad tech and household data, and therefore more pricing leverage over media buyers.
For Skydance and Warner, we expect even heavier bundling. Premium film and sport properties will be mixed with what David cheerfully calls the cardboard and filler. Agencies will be offered attractive access to the crown jewels, but only if they also move large volumes of lower quality inventory that is hard to sell on its own.
That is where advertisers are exposed. Once inventory is bundled at the holding company or agency level, it can appear on your media plan simply because it helps the agency clear a corporate deal, not because it will drive your brand's growth. And a classic example where an FMCG brand was spending heavily in Scotland despite having no distribution there, solely because the agency deal required it.
How should marketers be thinking?
First, do not confuse consolidation with automatic efficiency. A bigger seller with more data can be more efficient for itself while being less efficient for you. Never assume that a new mega owner will deliver lower cost per outcome unless you have evidence.
Second, interrogate every plan. Ask your media team and agency which line items exist to serve your growth strategy and which exist to serve somebody else's volume commitment. Where Fox style CTV bundles appear, insist on seeing what proportion of spend sits in truly premium environments versus the long tail.
Third, protect yourself through independent verification and governance. Our point is that as the market gets more consolidated and more automated, good governance is not a nice to have. It is the only way to spot when your money is being used to paper over somebody else's commercial agreements.
AI answer engines as the next walled gardens
AI answer engines are quickly shifting from being useful research tools to becoming full commercial marketplaces that route demand, monetize attention and capture first party data at scale.
In the episode, we talk about OpenAI's push to find a sustainable revenue model. On top of subscription tiers, OpenAI is now testing advertising as an income stream inside ChatGPT. External reporting shows that OpenAI has signed agreements with Magnite and PubMatic to help monetize ChatGPT inventory while keeping tight control of ad delivery and placement, as covered by The Myers Report.
We also discuss OpenAI's new business hub and brand agents. Marketers can intentionally feed product data into the model, spin up shopping or service agents, and get new forms of measurement back. That dramatically reduces the role of third party 'AI SEO' intermediaries who were trying to figure out how to game answer engines from the outside.
Structurally, this looks very similar to the early years of search marketing. A single player with frontier technology and proprietary data races to monetize attention, then builds tools and formats that brands must learn to use. The difference now is that CMOs are already far more numerate and suspicious. Media directors and even CFOs now regularly talk about log files and programmatic mechanics.
For advertisers, the implication is simple. ChatGPT and other answer engines will become another walled garden with its own bidding logic, measurement framework and data quirks. If you do not set a clear strategy, you will find budgets seeping into agentic AI activity without governance, and you will not be able to explain whether it is driving incrementally or just shifting conversions from other channels.
What The Trade Desk tells you about the open internet
The third story is The Trade Desk's Q3 wobble. Since 2020, The Trade Desk had not posted a single quarter of revenue decline. In this episode we pick up the Q3 2026 numbers where revenue landed at about 736 million dollars, down 0.5 percent year on year, according to The Trade Desk's own release on its investor site, mirrored in its Q3 2026 financial results.
Trade coverage from titles such as AdExchanger notes that profit fell more sharply and that the company relied on one off contributions and political advertising to hold the line. The symbolism matters. The Trade Desk is treated as a bellwether for the independent open internet, so any slowdown raises questions about the long term competitiveness of independent programmatic versus walled gardens.
Let's be blunt about what the market is signaling. When Google, Meta and Amazon can post double digit ad revenue growth at the same time an open internet champion is flat to slightly negative, the gravitational pull of the giants is obvious. Their combination of proprietary audiences, first party data and AI capability is hard to beat.
For CMOs, the risk is that spend concentrates even further in a handful of platforms by default, not by design. If independent options weaken, you lose negotiating leverage, you lose diversity in your media mix and you lose some of the competitive tension that keeps pricing honest.
How senior marketers should respond now
All three stories can be framed through one question. How do senior advertisers stay pitch ready, governance ready and AI ready at the same time, without being paralysed by noise?
The first step is to reframe consolidation as a governance challenge, not a discount opportunity. When a Skydance plus Warner type portfolio arrives on your desk wrapped in a beautiful narrative, treat it as a bundle of different risk profiles. Ask for clear breakouts of premium properties versus filler, and put your own value on each layer rather than buying the story whole.
The second step is to interrogate your plans line by line. David's Scotland example is not ancient history. In one FMCG engagement, ID Comms was asked why so much spend was in a region with no product distribution. The answer was simple. The agency had a volume commitment in that region, so the client's plan quietly picked up the slack.
The third step is to treat AI answer engines as a mainstream discipline, not a hobby. If we are right that ChatGPT scale is already in the billions of weekly interactions, you cannot afford a vague AI search plan. Define what an AI agent should be allowed to do for your brand, what data you will supply, how you will measure outcomes and who has final sign off.
Finally, double down on independent verification. As more of your buying is mediated by large platforms and opaque algorithms, you need someone in your corner who can reconcile what you are told with what actually happens. That means audits, log file analysis, cross channel attribution and contractual governance that keeps your walk away points clear.
If you recognize some of these dynamics in your own media plans and want a sounding board, get in touch to confidentially discuss your 'gameplan' and the options you have to protect your competitive advantage in media.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why are media owner mega mergers such a big deal for advertisers?
Because they change who controls data, inventory and pricing. When Fox owns Roku style CTV infrastructure and household data, it can bundle premium and lower quality inventory, then use that leverage in negotiations with agencies and, indirectly, with you.
2. Does consolidation always mean better pricing or efficiency?
No. We warn that bigger owners often prioritize margin protection. A Skydance plus Warner portfolio might deliver internal cost savings of 6 billion dollars, but that is not the same as better cost per outcome for your campaigns.
3. What practical questions should I ask about my media plans in this environment?
Ask which line items are there because they are proven growth drivers for your brand and which are there to fulfill portfolio or volume commitments. Ask which buys are bundled, how quality is defined and what proportion of your budget sits in the top tier of inventory.
4. How serious is the rise of AI answer engines for my media strategy?
It is serious enough that it deserves a defined strategy. OpenAI's deals with players such as Magnite and PubMatic show that ChatGPT inventory is being plugged into programmatic pipes. That means agentic AI will increasingly compete for the same budgets as search and social.
5. Is Google really at risk from OpenAI and other AI platforms?
We're skeptical that anyone will easily topple Google, given how profitable and entrenched search marketing is. The more realistic outcome is that AI answer engines become an additional walled garden you must manage, rather than a full replacement for search.
6. What does The Trade Desk's 0.5 percent revenue decline actually signal?
On its own, a 0.5 percent year on year revenue drop from 739 to 736 million dollars is small. Symbolically, it matters because it is the first backward step after years of growth and it comes at a time when the big three digital platforms are posting double digit increases.
7. Should I pull money out of the open internet because of The Trade Desk's results?
No. The message is not to abandon the open web, but to be intentional. Use independent buying routes where they add reach, data or contextual strength that walled gardens cannot match. Measure hard, and expect proof that open internet activity is incremental, not just cheaper.
8. How can procurement leaders add value in this environment?
By shifting from blunt price pressure to informed governance. Procurement can insist on transparency around bundling, demand third party verification of delivery and outcomes, and help codify when the organization pitches, renegotiates or holds nerve.
9. What should my first concrete AI action be as a CMO?
Ring fence a modest innovation fund and define one or two specific AI answer engine tests with clear success criteria. For example, a defined ChatGPT agent that helps a certain audience solve a problem, with agreed metrics and a fixed period for review.
10. When should I call ID Comms?
Call us when you suspect that consolidation, agency deals or AI hype are distorting your media decisions and you want an independent, practitioner level view. Sometimes that is before a pitch, sometimes before a renegotiation and sometimes when numbers simply do not add up.
Episode Transcript
Okay. Media consolidation continues. We're gonna look inside some of these massive media owner mega mergers in recent weeks, and we're gonna ask, what's the benefit to brands? Most important thing. AI search and answer engines are opening their doors to advertisers. Is that enough to really worry Google? And some pretty poor results out of Trade Desk. Is that a result of the Holdco commercial arguments from this year or does it show us a new trend in the open web? Live from New York. And live from London. It's Media Snack Live. Hello, I'm Tom Denford in New York. And I'm David Indo from London. Welcome to Media Snack Live. It's our weekly roundup of all the important news and stories and trends you need to know about the global media and marketing industry.
In every show we' ask, what' is going on? What are the implications for advertisers? And what should marketers be thinking about next? Thanks for joining us. Let's get into this week's show. Indeed, let's get into this week's show. Yes. So, uh, there's always a lot of stuff. We, I mean, we... Regular viewers will know, it was like, 'What should we talk about on Media Snack?' Because there's so many things. We're, like, trying to figure out actually the focus, uh, sometimes, and, uh, is a challenge. Not that you should- Mm ... feel bad for us- ... 'cause it's always fun.
Um, but we always take the view of, like, what's the best, best kind of executive briefing that we can give media leaders. So whether you're a marketer in m- you know, media procurement, whether you're an agency leader, or you work anywhere else in the kind of media and advertising ecosystem, you know, what are the kind of critical things to know? And we tend to look at the more structural tectonic stuff that's going on that's gonna have an impact, you know, help you hopefully make decisions, uh, in you- whatever role you have. So, that's what's some of this is focused off. There's, there's, there's some continued consolidation, isn't there, that I think we need to- Yeah ... be thinking of.
We talked a bit about- ... consolidation over the last year because of the trend. so what's going on? What's the latest consol- Well, I- ... in consolidation that we've got to navigate right now? Yeah. I'm, I'm gonna kind of highlight a couple of, uh, of deals that have kind of been done or going through, uh, recently that- Mm ... I think to me illustrate how the big kind of tech dominance is forcing the rest of the industry to try and kind of scale itself to compete. Yeah.
That's kind of my, my instinct on this. So, you know, we've just got Fox that has finally and officially concluded its 22 billion dollar acquisition- Mm-hmm ... of Roku. Mm. So with that, they get all of the kind of the inventory that Roku has ac- across multiple kind of platforms. But interestingly, and importantly, it also gets access to, uh, 100 million households globally. Mm. The streaming habits of these 100 million kind of households. Right. So, you kind of, you're thinking if you're a media owner, you know, where's the real kind of value in that? Is it in advertising revenue or is it in the data of the audience? It's the data, isn't it? Yep. It's the data, right? That's kind of- Amazing data business. Yep. Yeah.
So then you've got Skydance that has just, they acquired, uh, Warner Brothers. Mm-hmm. And they've just announced a 6 billion dollar cost reduction programme through the synergies. Yeah. Now, you know, for the, for the media industry, you know, what should be slightly alarming is within that 6 billion, 1 billion is a reduction in marketing investment. Yeah.
And then the other acquisition that is kind of recent is, is kind of DoorDash and the 17 billion dollar acquisition of Instacart. Again, you know, so you, so all of that kind of retail media data- Yeah ... is now kind of sitting within kind of DoorDash, and it's all about finding those kind of incremental, uh, value improvements that they can add in order to kind of generate kind of, kind of revenue. So- Yeah ... for me, it, it, it feels like, you know, who controls the most data- Mm-hmm ... who controls the most technology to make the most informed bets to drive greater revenue, we're gonna win.
Uh- Yeah ... and, uh, you know, we'll talk about the implications and, and what marketers should be thinking about. But, you know, these big seismic shifts in terms of acquisitions, consolidations, in a marketplace where, you know, 60 percent of the trillion dollars that we as an industry spend on media, uh, goes through essentially three platforms, Yeah ... it's, it's, it's, it's bonkers. Yeah. Yep.
so yeah, consolidation continues. Yeah. Really does. And as you say, it's a kind of fight for data, isn't it? I mean, that's, that's the, there's a big data control component in, in all of these deals, and as there has been in the agency consolidations that we've been talking about- Yeah ... and will continue to expect will probably continue.
in terms of some of the implications, the... I mean, on the Fox deal, that vertical integration in CTV kind of changes a bit of a power dynamic. Yeah. So, uh, Fox controls their, you know, that's a big, big, another big investment, as you say, but controls content, operating system, ad tech, and a serious amount of very valuable household data that- Yeah ... advertisers. are really keen to have a look at.
That, the, the, the, the idea, I think, behind that deal is it, it gives Fox significant price, pricing leverage, over media buyers. So that's the kind of- Yeah ... flag for advertisers there. I know you're gonna come on to some recommendations. Yes. There's, you know, DOJ interest in this, you know, there's regulator interest in this. These independent kind of ad tech vendors definitely, uh, are under pressure for margins and restricted access.
you know, particularly if they're, if they're, they're, you know, uh, preferring their own technology stack. Yeah. Then we've got the debt heavy media mergers. So Skydance Warner Brothers is, I think, an 8 billion dollar debt, uh, facility in that. Is that right? Is it 8 billion? I think so. 80 billion, sorry. Yeah. I mean, I thought I got that wrong. I was so- I didn't, didn't... These days, 8 billion does not sound like much, does it? Yeah. 8 billion sounds like a rounding error. Mm.
6 billion of worth of savings to come from- Smart ... an 80 billion dollar, you know, leverage on that. Uh, what you'd expect, I mean, across those Skydance Warner properties, you've got some real jewels in the crown, but the, you know, the crown itself is made of... There's a bit of cardboard in there and filler, isn't there?
so what you'd expect them to probably do to try to protect margins from, from all of their media inventory is to go aggressively bundling- Yeah ... now, even more so than they were before, to media agencies, and trying to get them to buy, you know, these, uh, they're a bit like these, you know, collateralized, merged bundles of media inventory. Mm.
so this s- this kind of deal serves the proprietary media, principle based media model- Yeah ... in theory, quite well because you've got some real, you've got some high quality stuff mixed in with a whole bunch of, you know, meh quality- Yeah ... uh, stuff, to use technical lang- language there, you know?
and that's what's gonna probably happen. So as a buyer, as an investor in media, as a marketer, procurement, uh, whoever's taking a look at this, when you're applying your good governance, as we do for our advertiser clients, uh, onto that media spend, you wanna be doing really good quality assessments because these kind of deals are really just gonna end up a l- a lot of bundling of low quality with a nice pie crust of good quality stuff on top.
Yeah. So be, be kind of aware of that, that low tier... And, and the way that often works sometimes, not only do they, they bundle together, but the, the deal to the agency buyer is, 'Look, we'll give you access to, you know, these premium properties as long as you commit to buy a ton of this other stuff that we haven't sold' Mm. 'Or we can't sell,' or whatever it is. Like, you know, l- lower grade stuff.
Now, there's no suggestion that the c- any one client gets the r- the same mixture of those two things. You wanna get the good stuff without having to, on your media plan, accept all the bad stuff, um, or the poor quality stuff. Mm. So, you know, you want to go, 'Give that to some other client of yours. I don't want that.'
that's what tends to happen, is that there's, there's- Yeah ... this, this arrangement with the, with the agency.
then, I mean, DoorDash and Instacart, I mean, that's a... I didn't see that one coming, and that was a really interesting one. again, another massive acquisition, isn't it? Yeah. You just don't, you can't kind of foresee sometimes these, these giant deals that are happening.
but the reason that they're able to raise the money or the investors are supportive of these acquisitions is the, is, like you said, is it creates new competition for- Yeah ... for marketing budget, like shopper marketing budget here. Mm. It creates a whole new walled garden, uh, with its own, you know, data, uh, and measurement complexity that, that comes with that. But it's leveraging the data as an asset, uh- Yeah ... in those businesses to, for the benefit of both, of both companies. Mm.
and it shows you the value there is and the competition there is for the, this kind of quality of data. Yeah.
what are the... So these are big things. These are big things kind of happening around you as a marketer. Yeah. So- You read the headlines. What, what, what is it, what do you, what does it mean for me? What decisions do I have to make? Well, that's right. And it can get really confusing. I mean, I do feel sorry for marketeers, you know. Like, just, life's not easy at the moment, you know? Yeah.
There's, everything's going on. There's, there's confusion in the marketplace on the agency side, there's confusion on the marketplace in the, in the retail media side, in the platform side. Everybody's getting bigger. The, the challenge, I think, is don't confuse, confuse consolidation necessarily with greater efficiency or effectiveness. Mm. That's, that's the, that's the first thing. So, don't assume that just because there is greater consolidation in the marketplace you are going to benefit either through greater productivity of your media investments or greater efficiency of those kind of investments.
Yeah. That's the first thing, so be wary. the second thing that I'm gonna say is it's even more important to interrogate the plan. As you, as you kind of rightly said, the implications are that these things get bundled up, and they just appear on the plan because they are part of a bigger deal. And, you know, there may be some collateral damage.
Y- keep... I always remember one example, Tom. You know how I like to- Yeah ... sprinkle the occasional- Yeah, we love these. Go on.
a number of years ago, you and I were working, uh, in the UK, uh, on a big FMCG business, and, uh, the business came to us and said, 'Can you look at a media plan for me? Because I am very confused why so much of my media investment is being invested in Scotland when I have no distribution in that part of the United Kingdom.' Now, it's an obvious choice, but the reason that Scotland appeared on the plan was not because there was any indication that they were trying to drive business growth Out of Scotland.
It was because the agency deal required a proportion pretty much of all clients' investment to go in that particular kind of region. Yeah. So even more important to kind of interrogate the plan. And- Yeah. And we, we have another more recent examples in, in the US now where, you know, that's the case where certain kind of geographies or audiences or channels are bundled in with lots of other stuff. I mean, it happens all the time. Yeah.
yeah. And then the third thing, and, and this is gonna be a consistent theme through the three stories that we kind of share today- Yeah ... is, you know, protect yourselves by independent verification and governance. Really, really important. The more confusing, the more complicated, the more dynamic, the more fragmented, even through consolidation- Yeah ... the market becomes, it's really, really important that you have some form of governance protocol and process in place that allows you to, uh, identify when things just don't feel right, when things aren't quite going wrong, and so that they're able to kind of course correct and raise those yellow flags, those amber flags, and red flags- Yeah ... if there is something kind of wrong.
So, uh, you know, that, those would be my, that would be my kind of advice to, to marketeers. Yeah. Very good.
these are not isolated things, they're just part of a continued trend- Yeah ... you know, of consolidation. It's kind of like a fight for monopoly power, isn't it? I mean, if- Yeah ... uh, and there's, there's, at the moment there doesn't seem much regulatory resistance to these very big deals. Now maybe that changes, but certainly in the US, you know, the conditions seem to be encouraging these kind of consolidations. Mm-hmm.
There may be some efficiencies that come from that. I mean, certainly in America maybe they kind of think, 'Well, in, in the US that kind of maintains American dominance.' You know, they like having- Yeah ... these kind of very large scale companies.
but there are some maybe trickle down warnings, as you say, because they kind of... These players are starting to approach in a mon- monopolistic kind of scale. Yeah. And those tend to not be good for consumers. They're not necessarily long term good for the market. Yeah.
you know, it... And I think a lot of these deals probably are being justified on infrastructure cost, data, you know, can serve the customer better by knowing more, you know- Yeah ... cross selling off, you know, offering more choice, all this kind of stuff. Mm-hmm.
But the reality is for a marketer on a B2B level, behind the scenes as a marketer, yeah, you c- you, you, you, you're gonna maybe lose some transparency in what you're buying and the value of what you get. So that's why we, we love doing these kind of independent, you know, analyses of, of- Yeah ... advertisers' media spending and, you know, checking the governance on their, on their investments because we can normally shine, you know, a good light on just some things that can be improved, and it just gives you money back. It just gives you- Yeah. Absolutely ... extra money in your, in your marketing pocket- Yeah ... um, to do more stuff, which is great. We love doing stuff. Mm-hmm. Again, another technical term. Yeah.
Um- Go on. What's this next story? Right. Next one is, um, a little bit of an update, just again, it's, uh, kind of a technology story. Uh, OpenAI- Yeah ... um, you know, through ChatGPT have, as we've discussed before, you know, have been kind of testing, at scale now, testing advertising as an, as an income stream.
As you know, though, these businesses, particularly, you know, OpenAI and Anthropic, who... They need a revenue stream, you know? It's just going, 'Oh, we just, we're spending a lot of money. We- maybe we should make some money as well.' Uh, advertising looks like the most obvious place to do that, and it seems to be the less, potentially less painful way of doing it, rather than just trying to charge customers for services. At some point they probably will obviously move to, you know, subscription tiers of course, and they'll, those will probably be very expensive once we get, uh, very addicted to it. Yeah.
It's become, been called the Uberification of, of, of AI, you know, which is the, that's the business model is that, you know, subsidize and then, and then prices kind of creep up over time- Yeah ... and to a, to a kind of market level that the market can tolerate.
We're all getting very addicted to this stuff. We'll probably be end up paying a bit. But in the meantime, they sugarcoat that pill by saying, 'We're gonna run advertising as well.' So there'll be advertising tiers to it. Uh, in the same way that advertising is now subsidizing for many users Netflix and, and other platforms. It was supposed to be ad free, and now they're not ad free. Yeah.
Cause advertising is the tax that you pay if you don't wanna pay the full subscription price. That's just what we pay. Mm-hmm. So they're playing with ad models. It's kind of interesting. And the first set of results are now coming out.
OpenAI have also launched this business hub and business agents, uh, this week, which is kind of interesting, which, uh, which for brands allows you to intentionally feed the model details about your products. You can, uh, spin up, you know, dedicated shopping agents for your customers. Um, and then, and just g- get lots of kind of new data and metrics out of it.
Uh, I think the idea is that they want to undercut this cottage industry that's now a big global industry, which is like the new version of, you know, uh, gen AI searching, the new versions of SEO that marketers are throwing money at now trying to go, 'How do we show up in all of these kind of suggestion engines?'
Um, ChatGPT I think is trying to shortcut that- Mm ... get some of that money directly themselves so that we're not, third parties are not optimizing ChatGPT. They're saying, 'Come optimize on our platform, but pay us some money for it.' Yeah.
that's kind of interesting and it's, it, it potentially lays the groundwork here for, for some form of like sponsored brand agents I think. Yeah. You can find brands building their own- ... kind of service agents perhaps within- Yeah ... within, uh, OpenAI's platform. So that's kind of interesting. That's, uh, you know, something of course marketers need to keep an eye on.
they're in a race here. Personally, I st- this is not investment advice, and I don't ever give anybody investment advice, 'cause I'm the worst person to think about. But that, but we do see that, we see the tectonic plates, as I say, and, um, I find it very hard to see how, how these companies topple Google? as being- Mm ... the dominant player. I mean, I understand that they have frontier technology, and they're investing a huge amount in the infrastructure of that.
and their model's in places superior, and the technology- Yeah ... is superior to what Google's doing. But you've gotta have a, you've gotta have a revenue stream. I mean, it's just very hard- Yeah ... to kind of really see how they truly monetize. And I'm not sure the world is dripping with cash, you know? I don't think consumers are- Mm ... yet right ready to pay. So at, uh, there's a lot of pressure on them to get their advertising model right. Yeah.
Yeah. And you're going up against Google, which has created the most successful, profitable business model ever invented, which is search marketing- Mm ... strangely. Who'd have thought? But that is, that is the best, most valuable business model ever created. Mm.
And they've gotta figure out how to work around that, uh- I'm sure they'll get an algorithm to... They'll ask ChatGPT what the, what the right- Yeah, we should try that ... revenue model is. Maybe we can come up with a new Google.
but I mean, that's the fundamentals at play here. So the pressure to get advertising correct for these- Yeah ... businesses. And they've been, they've, you know, they've hired, um, tons of amazing ad people to kind of try and figure this stuff out.
that's huge pressure. So we kind of keep an eye on that, and we speak to a lot of- Yeah ... marketers now that are, you know, starting to see them. They're another platform, another walled garden, another potential partner stroke threat to their business. Another thing for the CMO to be kind of very, very wary of. I know. But you need a strategy. If you're a CMO- Yeah ... absolutely, you need a strategy behind it, right?
Well, let's just, let's just jump to some of the things that, that, um, you know, implications and advice on that.
Um- Well, yeah ... I think we were gonna talk about Amazon. I think we'll talk about the kind of Amazon findings. We- we'll pick that up next week, 'cause that's kind of another- Yeah ... interesting related topic that we probably don't have time for. Yeah. But, um, uh-
So I think, I mean, for me, you've got- I've got ChatGPT, what, 1.6, 1.2 billion weekly kind of users. There's a big audience there, and that's gonna- Mm ... kind of increase. And it's increasingly becoming like a commercial kind of marketplace.
So evolving, as you say, from kind of information and recommendations to actually being an opportunity where brands can engage with consumers. And if, if that proves lucrative for brands as a way of actually getting, uh, consumers to buy products through ChatGPT, then that's- Yeah ... only gonna go for- so basically, you're, you're bypassing the search side of it, and you're going directly through to consumer to execution and, and, and, and, and revenue generation. I think that's really kind of, kind of very powerful. Yeah.
And I think it will soon become, if it hasn't already become, a mainstream marketing discipline. So, uh, for marketeers, they really need to have a geo strategy in place, and not a- Yeah ... not a nascent one. It has to be a fully developed one. But with that, again, and this is kind of that consistent theme that I'm sharing, um, transparency becomes even more important, uh, as advertising becomes more automated. Yeah.
So for, for, for marketeers to have that independent governance verification as it seems almost everything becomes far more automated and dynamic, becomes really, really important. Mm. Because if you kind of lose control of the reins with this, you just never know where it's gonna stop.
So I think having those protocols in place early as more and more of these kind of marketing disciplines become more important within your kind of marketing, uh, strategy and your media plan, I think it's really important to have that kind of governance protocol in place, uh, at the very beginning- Yeah ... and, and imposed on top of all of these platforms and channels where you're investing more and more money. Yeah.
It makes me... I've just, uh... Would we wanna be media directors these days? I, I dunno. I mean, I- You have very good advice, but I also think, God, I mean, it's so much to take on, isn't it? Yeah. It's such a lot. What's your advice to, you know, your contemporaries, your media directors that you speak to every week? How are they feeling?
My, my... Well, they're, I think they're quite excited. but they... I tell you what they are feeling more than anything else. They are feeling paranoid that somebody else has figured it all out and they haven't. Mm. And the reality is that nobody has. Yeah. That everybody is fumbling somewhat in the dark.
There are some businesses that are a little bit more progressive, that they've, uh, imposed, uh, innovation test and learn strategies, as they're a little- Yeah ... bit more advanced in terms of their kind of thinking and, and, and, uh, the kind of the learnings that they've got.
but if it, for me, if I was in place, I would, uh, understand very quickly what works for my business and make sure that I've doubled down on that, and then I would bring out a innovation fund that would allow me to kind of advance in terms of my kind of thinking, and figure out where I should be placing the big bets moving forward. Yeah. Yeah. Very good. Very good.
As I mentioned, last week, I th- I, I spoke at a, a conference called the MIRAN Conference, which is a kind of agency- Yeah ... new business thing. And, and w- uh, the panel we had, which was, uh, which I was on with a, a few, uh, of our peers, you know, cons- con- from the consulting community, and mostly they were f- they focused more on- ... creative, we tend to be more media. Yeah.
And the acknowledgement there amongst- was their suggestion is that media thinking in AI- Mm ... is, like, one lap ahead the creative side. So I thought, 'Oh, you know, that's a really interesting kind of perspective,' 'cause I thought creative and production was being really kind of- Yeah ... really pushing innovative.
They think... This is on the, this is on the client side, I should say. Sorry. Yeah. I don't mean the agency. On the client side. The, the, the, the media director- Yeah ... is actually- has been really leaning in, as you say. You know, the, nobody's got it figured out, but actually they do tend to come into the room with a bit more of a view of, of how the technology and automation is gonna- Mm ... is gonna help on the media side. And maybe it's easy because, easier because it's very data rich and it's- Yeah ... more logical, all that stuff.
Um, I thought it was a really interesting observation. Mm.
okay. Uh, we'll keep an eye on that one. I th- I'm j- I'm really curious- Mm ... as I say, the, on how their ad models are going to evolve. so I think that's something that we'll continue to track. Yeah. We do, and advise our clients, we'll continue to kind of track- Mm ... and we'll share that with you on Media Snack.
Okay. Third up, Trade Desk. How was- Yeah ... Trade Desk's Q3? Everyone was kind of curious because it's kind of a, it's kind of an indicator, isn't it, maybe? Yeah. But also, it was, it's the last of the big tech, uh, businesses to share their Q3 results. Yeah. So, you know, we did an entire episode on, uh, Amazon and Google and, and, and Meta's- Mm ... double digit Q- Q3 year on year- Yeah ... kind of growth. And everybody was, you know, it was, everything was amazing. And we just assumed- It was embarrassingly good, wasn't it? Yeah. It was embarrassingly good. I'm going, 'Where's all this money coming from?' you know? Yeah.
I mean, the, the market's only increasing at 3 or 4 percent each year, yet they're- Yeah ... driving double digit growth. It's remarkable. Yeah. And, and, and then you've got Trade- The Trade Desk. that, that reports a little bit later. Now, remember, The Trade Desk, since 2020, had not had one quarter where it was going backwards. Yeah. So every single quarter showing significant- Incredible business ... incredible business. Yeah.
Apart from this quarter. No. And its revenue year on year has declined by half a percent. So- Mm-hmm ... small in relative terms, but is this a trend? Who knows, right? So for the first time in, uh, five years, this business has shown a decline in year on year kind of revenues.
Um, and this is the bellwether, if you like, of kind of independent tech businesses and- Mm ... you know, outside of the wall gardens. And so, you know, that's, that's an interesting... I think that's an interesting insight in the marketplace. Yeah.
It is. I mean, uh, it definitely is. It, it's the canary in the coalmine, potentially- Yeah ... isn't it, for the open internet. I mean, that's what p- other people are saying. I think that's- Yeah ... that's, that is more than jingoistic. I think that's probably true.
it does raise those questions of how competitive long term, uh, you know, this independent programmatic advertising model is. We don't know. Mm. Uh, those big tech... F- I mean, just, we, again, we're kind of astounded by the continued growth of big tech- Mm.
in terms of the ad- advertising. Their advantage are very hard to compete against. You know, we talked about just now, you know, how hard it was gonna be for OpenAI and Anthropic and others to kind of- Yeah ... challenge Google's fundamental, highly profitable business model. Very, very difficult,, when these platforms also have proprietary audiences, they have first party data. They have, you know, owned inventory and own managed inventory, and then increasingly sophisticated because they are also AI companies as well.
You know, Google, Meta, and Amazon, they are advertising businesses. Mm. You know, they, I mean, some more than others, but, you know, Meta is 93 percent ad- Yeah ... advertising. Okay? Yeah.
Uh, Amazon has now created a m- you know, multi, multi, multi billion dollar business. We always said that maybe they would overtake Meta one day, but they haven't yet done that. Yeah.
advertising money, that's where this comes from. Uh, the, uh, it raises questions over maybe the long term validity of the open internet as a kind of advertising, long term advertising, uh, opportunity. But from the marketer's perspective, let's just quickly touch on some of those things. Yeah.
It concentrates ad spend even further, doesn't it? Yeah. And that scares me. Yeah. We- That would worry me. Yeah. We want Trade Desk and we want indep- the independent and the open web? to be really viable. They were supposed to be the, you know, the, the poster child for, for how safe and, and reassuring- Yeah ... and, and powerful open internet could be. When that doesn't look so good for Trade Desk, it' does start to suggest that marketers are losing confidence in open web, and that's, that's- Mm ... probably not a good thing. For the world, it's not a good thing- Yeah ... for the world really, is it?
Exactly right. Exactly right.
okay. Wrapping up- Yeah ... uh, in the 20 seconds that we've got. Did... I saw that Omnicom had picked up the Lufthansa global media business. That was a big kind of global media pitch announcement- Mm-hmm ... this week. Bit of a pain for WPP. That was a 20 something year relate- 25 year relationship, shifted. And as is becoming the way, Lufthansa, in their statement, used the word AI in the opening sentence. I mean, I said this on the panel the other day, I was like, AI is not just making the decision. I mean, the market is not making a decision because of AI. We're not, that's not the only evaluation. But my goodness, it's the top of the brief. I mean, it' really is, and it's the top of the press release, and that tells you everything. Mm.
I think, and, and that's the stuff that worries investors, I think, about WPP. I mean, maybe they're not competing on? the AI side, which they should be, 'cause we've seen their stuff and it's really good. Yeah. So- Maybe, maybe it's not landing it well enough. Yeah.
Yeah. And, and- That's what I think ... and Omnicom, you know, since the kind of bloody nose that they took a few months ago, uh, maybe have, uh, you know, focused their proposition and their narrative in a far more, you know, directive and sharp way. Yeah. Well, they- Obviously ... landed Lufthansa, I'd say, so good for them.
Okay. Very good. Uh, that's it for the next, this week. See you next? time on Media Snack. See you then. Thanks for watching Media Snack Live. If you found it helpful and want to learn more, head to idcoms.com to get more tips, tools, and resources to help you get good at media. We'll see you next week.

COMMENTS